A Blog of Very Little Brain

'What does Crustimoney Proseedcake mean?' said Pooh. 'For I am a Bear of Very Little Brain, and long words Bother me.'

Free as in Forgetaboutit?

with 2 comments

I’ve recently visited Mozilla‘s site, where I found a link to “Firefox Flicks“, which, if memory serves me right, was a contest where users created and submitted home-made commercials.

Now, with Firefox being both the “IE killer” and the iconic Free Software product, I was mostly expecting something that will, at least in some vague way, address those, and other benefits of the browser. However, from looking at the aforementioned page, I quickly realised it was not to be so. What I didn’t expect was my inability to actually view those “flicks”.

You see, the video clips were presented in Flash. Yep, a non-free, proprietary format, which my computer doesn’t support (Both for idealistic and practical reasons). Fortunately, the good folks at Mozilla offer a download option, where you can get the clips. In QuickTime format.

What exactly happened here? Either the Mozilla guys forgot what actually puts bread on their tables, which is the Free Software concept, without which they’d be where Netscape is now (which is nowhere), or they hired a marketing company who doesn’t even know what’s Free Software, and thinks God farts in Flash. Either way, bad move.

Sadly, it doesn’t end there.
As I’ve recently mentioned, I played a bit with Damn Small Linux. When I got to their download section, a weird file, named “GPL_Sources.txt” caught my eye. The text file included with the downloaded files had this to say: “We honnor the GPL (sic) and will send anybody the sources to the GPL software in Damn Small.
If you want to receive copies of the software please send us $7 (cost of media and shipping) and we will gladly mail you the sources.

Now, I’m not a GPL expert, but it seems weird to me that a Free product (both Liber and Gratis) will demand money for sharing its source code, the holy pinnacle of the Free Software concept. And we’re not talking about some forsaken application here, we’re talking about a GNU/Linux distro. For comparison, if Firefox is the icon Free Software product, GNU/Linux is the Flagship. More so, Damn Small is based on Debian, a 100% communitee project that is also boasting a Free Software Social Contract.

In both cases, we’re dealing with people and companies who spit into the well they drink from. Neither Damn Small nor Firefox would’ve existed without Free Software. Dissing the Free Software concepts, is just not Cricket.

Written by Erez

Tuesday, June 13, 2006 at 21:40

2 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. […] I’ve mentioned Firefox less-than-total commitment to the Free Software concept in previous posts. It would seem that those guys from Mozilla got the whole deal more than a little bit off. As this article shows, not only does they trademarked the Firefox logo, but also have a clause that stipulating that using Firefox name without the official branding is a trademark violation. Don’t use the Firefox name, you say? Why, thank you, say Debian. Especially since that would release them of the other obligation, that any updates/patches they make to Firefox have to get approved by Mozilla before being implemented. This really gives the whole “FOSS” (Free and Open-Source Software) concept a new twist. […]

  2. […] You read that right. Consumer Protection. For the sake of all that is good and holy. How and when did the cornerstone of Free-Software become Microsoft? Oh sorry. Make that “cornerstone of Open-Source”. After all, they never did care about Freedom. Consumer protection my foot. The only thing they need to protect their consumers is against themselves, Digital Restriction Management-stylee. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: